Your complimentary articles
What Aria is featured in shawshank redemption and who sang it? It is called 'Sul'aria' - from the opera Marriage of Figaro by Mozart. The music is written in Italian even though Mozart was not - it. Sung like angels, the voices on this song are just incredible. I first heard this song on the movie Shawshank Redemption and was blown away. I jut knew I needed to add it to my collection. Definitely a good choice. Stephen King’s novella “ Rita Hayworth and Shawshank Redemption ” rounded up as The Shawshank Redemption. Its mix of the cold gray and bleak existence within prison walls buoyed by the light of hope resounded like few before. The adaptation accomplished another rare feat.
You’ve read one of your four complimentary articles for this month.
You can read four articles free per month. To have complete access to the thousands of philosophy articles on this site, please
Films
Alexander Hooke finds hell & existentialist hope in prison.
Hope helps keep us alive and anticipating the next sunrise with joy rather than gloom. It enlivens projects and maintains focus. Hope is sustained by the confidence we have in our knowledge of the situation, although the possibility of being deceived, by others or ourselves, can undermine this confidence. Still, hope promises a time or place where things will be better, even if it seems we’re stuck in perpetual hell. Accounts through the millennia depict hell as a realm full of fascinating and ghastly demons, endless tortures, with Satan ruling with a fiery fist, and where hope is impossible. Such wild accounts seem as if they belong to another world. But The Shawshank Redemption (1994) portrays a worldly dimension of hell: prison.
Based on the novella Rita Hayworth and The Shawshank Redemption by Stephen King, the film begins in the state of Maine in 1947. A young, successful banker named Andy Dufresne (Tim Robbins) has been convicted of murdering his wife and her golf-pro lover. Having motive, opportunity, and no credible alibi, Andy nevertheless insists on his innocence until the end. When he enters Shawshank Prison – whose façade simulates a palace or ancient cathedral – Andy’s protestations of innocence fall on deaf ears. Every convict there says he has been betrayed by a biased jury, corrupt judge or incompetent lawyer – one exception being Red (Morgan Freeman), a long-time con who admits, and regrets, the murder he committed when young and stupid. Red is the narrator of the movie, and through his eyes the audience gains insight to Sartre’s renowned remark about hell being other people. At the same time, there are moments in Red’s story about Shawshank and Andy that illuminate the shortcomings in Sartre’s vision of hell.
Andy and Red find friendship in Shawshank hell
Shawshank stills © Columbia Pictures 1994
Never and Always
![Redemption Redemption](/uploads/1/1/8/7/118769099/825550028.jpg)
Sartre’s notion that ‘hell is other people’ perhaps begins with his analysis of ‘the look’ in Being and Nothingness (1943), where individuals are struggling to retain their freedom against others’ objectifying gazes. In Sartre’s play No Exit (1944), the phrase is preceded by the notion that the eyes of others are devouring. In the play, Garcin and Estelle eventually begin desiring one another; but Inez, trapped in the same room, maintains a relentless gaze upon them. Despite Garcin’s pleas, Inez insists that darkness will never come for the potential lovers and that she will always be watching them. It is her gaze and this sense of endlessness that condemns the potential lovers.
‘Never’ and ‘always’ form integral components of hell. In his study on hell through the ages, The Fear of Hell (1987), Piero Camporesi says that according to a medieval text, “The door of that fatal resting place of all evil will be locked by two great iron keys: by Never and by Always… And who can tell me how much suffering two so short syllables, Never and Always, which form horrible eternity, can bring?” (p.36)
Camporesi also notes that rather than separating the universe into halves (heaven and hell), numerous thinkers held that the universe has three floors: the top is heaven and the bottom hell, with the middle – that is, the human world – containing elements of both. Here humans get a sense of damnation by suffering from their own excessive indulgences.
The world of Shawshank Prison dwells on the middle and lower floors of this universe. When Andy Dufresne arrives, the prison veterans take bets on which fresh fish (new inmate) will cry for his mother after hearing the cell doors clanking tight for the first night. The man who cried died after a savage beating by the prison captain.
As a God-fearing man, the warden introduces new convicts to one rule: respect the Lord and never take His name in vain. After that, the warden continues, “the Lord looks after your soul, but your ass belongs to me.” There are also groups of inmates called ‘Sisters’ or ‘Bull Queers’ – sexual predators who enjoy violent force with their pleasures – including a little circle of Sisters who periodically assault Andy.
The warden determines which convicts receive favors, tough assignments, or harsh penalties. Notwithstanding his numerous citations of the Bible, the warden does not sustain general law. He becomes a law unto himself by mirroring the behaviour of Satan – arbitrariness, cruelty, and endless punishment. When Andy discovers that there is a witness who can confirm his innocence of the double murder, the warden has the witness murdered and gives Andy a month of solitary confinement. And when Andy warns that he will stop using his banking skills to help the warden launder prison funds into his own bank account, the warden adds another month of solitary.
Beyond Silence and Darkness
Are humans the only species to punish one of their own with solitary confinement? Solitary is one of the most widely used forms of punishment today, although in terms of its effects on the victim, ‘torture’ might be a more accurate term. It disrupts and disorients a convict’s sense of time and space, as the victim sees and hears nothing save for his own breathing and heartbeat. Being released from solitary and rejoining the other convicts conveys a perverse sense of freedom.
Red is not fooled by this grim irony. He points out that after many years in jail, the walls begin to define a man: “These walls are funny. First you hate ‘em, then you get used to them. Enough time passes, you get so you depend on them.” Such resignation echoes Sartre’s central themes in his lecture Existentialism and Humanism (1946), where he describes freedom as a project that demands on-going and resilient attention. Without such attention, one can quickly lapse into letting others or institutions define one’s self.
An example of resilience occurs when Andy, who is eventually granted access to the administrative offices, broadcasts a Mozart aria over the intercom. Red, like other inmates, is transfixed by the surprise of the heavenly voices pervading the prison yard: “It was like some beautiful bird flapped into our drab little cage, and made those walls dissolve away. And for the briefest of moments, every last man in Shawshank felt free.”
For this mischief Andy is confined for two weeks in solitary. Upon release his buddies are startled that he seems so relaxed, knowing the unique horror of no contact with the world for days on end. Andy reminds them of Mozart’s music, and how something so beautiful helps maintain an inner sense of hope. Most of all, as he reminds them, you can’t let the guards, warden, parole board, even other prisoners, destroy this inner sense. Here beauty and hope are interwoven.
Hope is… Another Person
Notwithstanding the existentialist insights of The Shawshank Redemption, several scenes highlight shortcomings in Sartre’s notion that hell is other people.
Andy is at first a fairly isolated individual. He first comes to know Red as a customer, since Red buys and sell contraband for the inmates. Through Red, Andy learns that prison is a mini-society: life at Shawshank contains potential alliances, collaborations and reciprocally fruitful associations, even in the relations between guards and inmates – including the warden and his right-hand captain.
Andy comes to recognize the need for some sort of general camaraderie. A poignant moment occurs during the early pleasant days of Spring when the warden needs a crew to tar a rooftop. Red bribes the guards to fix the selection process so that he and his buddies, including Andy, get to enjoy the outdoors. Overhearing the captain – the one who savagely beat the new inmate to death – complain about how he will lose a considerable portion of his inheritance to taxes, Andy risks his life to ask the captain if he trusts his wife. Before the insulted captain can push Andy off the roof, Andy quickly explains that there’s a law permitting the captain to give the inheritance to his wife and no taxes will be taken. Andy even offers his services to bring this about to the captain; all he asks in return is for the warden to reward Andy’s co-workers some cold beers for their hard work. For the time it took the convicts to drink three colds beers each, says Red, they felt like free men. Red and Andy realize a true friendship is emerging. They mull over their options: “get busy livin’ or get busy dying.” After this, Andy uses his considerable skills to expand and beautify the library, process the tax returns of the guards, intervene when old-timer Brooks threatens to stab an inmate, and even mentor a young convict so he can earn his high school diploma. Andy finally confides to Red how he has funneled some of the warden’s ill-gotten booty into private funds under a fictitious name, passport and social security, known only to himself. Red could have earned immediate parole by relaying this information to the warden. Red’s only response is joyful laughter at the situation’s absurdity and his friend’s brilliant strategy.
However, Andy does not tell Red about the tunnel he has been digging for the last twenty years. He is possibly doing his friend a favor while improving his own chances for escape. After all, it will require plodding through five hundred yards of sewage to get outside the prison walls, and Red is probably not up to it physically. Instead, after Andy’s escape, Red finally earns parole. He goes to a tree in a New England meadow where Andy told Red he would bury a package. Red finds it and, true to his word, Andy has left an envelope of cash and letter of encouragement for Red to join him in Mexico, which he does.
Divergent Conclusions
The conclusion to the film has sparked considerable debate. Stephen King’s novella simply ends with Red professing a litany of “I hope” expressions for freedom and eventual reunion with his friend. Although the film originally closed with Red taking a bus to Mexico, the final cut was changed to a panoramic shot of a Mexican beach, Andy and Red embracing. Before test audiences, the embrace version elicited far more enthusiastic responses than the bus-over-the-hill version.
The film critic Mark Kermode makes a compelling argument in his book The Shawshank Redemption (2003), that the final film version is aesthetically and thematically unwarranted: it panders to popular sentiment, and underestimates the audience’s ability to understand the hope illuminated by the bus taking off for Mexico. In any event, the novella and the film both present a sharp contrast to the ending in No Exit. Sartre concludes with a scenario of his three individuals resigning themselves to the fact that they will never escape and always haunt one another. By contrast, Red and Andy either enjoy or envision a moment where the infinite scrutiny of others is replaced with the hope for the freedom in sharing warmth, joy and good humor with another. This freedom is called friendship.
© Alexander E. Hooke 2014
Alexander E. Hooke teaches philosophy at Stevenson University, USA. He is editor of Virtuous Persons, Vicious Deeds, and a co-editor of Encounters With Alphonso Lingis.
Music has the power to say so much more than we can see… So many movies have tried to express this idea, but The Shawshank Redemption was very good in doing that, and it was done through a single scene. An opera song floating in the air and doing incredible charming effect on the prisoners minds and souls.
The Shawshank Redemption opera song
One of the greatest scenes in film history is from the great film “The Shawshank Redemption”.
The shawshank redemption opera scene embodied the spirit of the film’s story, when the wrongly imprisoned, Andy Dufresne (Tim Robbins), locks himself in the prison office in an act of defiance against prison authorities and plays “Duettino- Sull’aria” aria duet from one of Mozart’s most popular operas “The Marriage of Figaro” over the loudspeakers, creating a sense of euphoria throughout the prison yard.
Related Playlist: Calm Opera
And hardened prisoners who haven’t seen the world outside the prison walls for ages, just stood open-mouthed, silenced by the arresting beauty of a sudden soothing music coming from a machine that orders them to do things. It was like the one hope left in the world, which for them it probably was… for moments, every prisoner at Shawshank felt free.
Also, the guards in the courtyard, hospital and in the workplaces were also brought to silence, maybe the were shocked like the prisoners and appreciated the beauty of the situation, believing that such a thing cannot exist in a gloomy place like this prison.
Red (Morgan Freeman), a fellow inmate, providing a voice-over narration, comments, “II have no idea to this day what those two Italian ladies were singing about. Truth is, I don’t want to know. Some things are best left unsaid. I’d like to think they were singing about something so beautiful, it can’t be expressed in words, and makes your heart ache because of it. I tell you, those voices soared higher and farther than anybody in a gray place dares to dream. It was like some beautiful bird flapped into our drab little cage and made those walls dissolve away, and for the briefest of moments, every last man in Shawshank felt free.”
It is so sad to think human are denied the music that can mend souls. However, I think this scene deserves Oscars for the acting , music , colors , Morgen Freeman’s voice …
Related playlist: Mozart Relax
Who is the opera singer in the shawshank redemption ?
The recording they used in the movie was made in 1968, many years later with Deutsche Oper Berlin Duettino conducted by Karl Bohm. The two “Italian” ladies were the German born Austrian lyric soprano Gundula Janowitz and her contemporary the Swiss soprano Edith Mathis.
Janowitz was von Karajan’s favourite singer and one of the most renowned opera singers of the 20th century. Mathis was a leading exponent of the works of Mozart. Their recording of “Canzonetta sull’aria” from “The Marriage of Figaro” opera is widely considered the best in existence. listen to original opera song from shawshank redemption in the video below.
Also discover: Best opera songs in the world
What are they singing about?
They’re actually singing about their plan to trick the Count. In this scene from Mozart’s opera “The Marriage of Figaro”, the Countess Rosina was left alone and she ponders over the loss of her happiness. Susanna, her maid, enters and updates her regarding the plan to trap the Count.
The Countess dictates a love letter for Susanna to send to the Count, asking him to meet susana secretly , “under the pines”. The letter instructs the Count to return the pin which fastens the letter. In this duet, the Countess dictates the title and the three lines of the letter and, after a pause, Susanna repeats the lines as she writes them. In the later part of this duet, the Countess and Susanna read alternate lines with a slight overlap (bars 38–45) until they finish in a true duet with their conclusion.
Discover opera playlists on Chosic:
Best Opera AriasExplore the wonders of opera with this selection of the… .
Countertenor – Highest Male VoiceClassical male singers with countertenor (contra tenor) voice type, which… .
Italian Opera SongsA playlist of the greatest and most beautiful Italian Opera… .
Shawshank Redemption opera song lyrics in english:
The content of Countess’ letter was:
On the breeze
What a gentle little zephir
A little zephir
This evening will sigh
This evening will sigh
Under the pines in the little grove.
Under the pines…
Under the pines in the little grove
Under…the pines…in the little grove
And the rest he’ll understand
Certainly, certainly he’ll understand.
What a gentle little zephir
A little zephir
This evening will sigh
This evening will sigh
Under the pines in the little grove.
Under the pines…
Under the pines in the little grove
Under…the pines…in the little grove
And the rest he’ll understand
Certainly, certainly he’ll understand.
Related Posts
12 most famous pop opera singers in the music worldSome say: 'Opera singers are the professors and pop singers… .
Best opera songs ever | 20 Most popular opera arias of all timesIt is a a great experience to listen to Opera… .
The Phantom of the Opera: story, movie and cello coverThere are rumors that the opera house in paris is… .
Discover Playlists
Instrument: Bouzouki.
Mozart RelaxRelaxing music from the classical genius Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart. A… .
Beautiful music on ViolaClassical works on Viola instrument, Viola covers and arrangements for… .